Click here for a Ukrainian translation by Anna Matesh.
New: PowerPoint stories for teaching the confusable letters b and d.
This website has everything you need to help children solve the b/d conundrum: https://sites.google.com/view/confusableletters/home
Many children have problems mixing up letters like b and d, p and q, m and n, and other letters. How do children learn letters?
The common-sense view that we learn letters by memorizing their shapes turns out to be wrong. A letter is recognized by its sequence of features, not as a whole shape. For example, letter mis made with a short line down, followed by two humps to the right.
Since letter recognition depends on understanding a sequence of features, the best way to teach children the sequence of features in making a letter is by guiding printing practice. For instance, it is extraordinarily helpful for children confusing letters b and d to practice printing d in the sequence, “First little c, then little d.” Sue Dickson, creator of the program Sing, Spell, Read, and Write, has developed many such helpful adages to guide printing practice with letters. I have transcribed her list below.
You can watch Sue explain how to teach letters in this YouTube video.
Here is a diagram showing the Zaner-Bloser directions for printing letters:
As the diagram indicates, letters are usually drawn from top to bottom and from left to right. Top-down and left-to-right are the easiest motions for the hand. Right and left are important concepts about print for learning letters. Using the directions indicated by the arrows in letter formation puts the hand in position for the next letter.
Using primary paper with guidelines helps children learn the relative size and position of letter features. Using plain paper is not “creative”; it makes it harder for children to learn the relative sizes and positions of the features.
Young children learning letters need vivid, concrete language to remember the abstract features that make up letters. It helps to name the lines on primary paper. I like calling the top line the “rooftop,” the dotted crossing line the “fence,” the bottom line the “sidewalk,” and the space beneath the sidewalk the “ditch.” Others like to use indoor names, such as the ceiling, windows, floor, and basement.
The script below suggests ways to use vivid, concrete language to guide children as they form letters. For example, to make the lower-case b, start at the rooftop, drop straight down to the sidewalk, and then b-b-bounce back up to the fence and around. Briefly, you drop down, bounce up, and around. After making a few letters with the teacher’s guidance, children need to talk themselves through the formation of letter features, saying to themselves, “Drop down, bounce up, and around.”
Daily writing opportunities encourage children to invent spellings, a key innovation from whole language. When students stretch pronunciations, they identify phonemes and symbolize them with letters, providing valuable practice with phoneme awareness. In a landmark study (Clarke, 1988), children who devised invented spellings during first grade were better than children who were provided spellings in word recognition and in spelling. The reason they were better is that constant practice inventing spellings developed their phoneme awareness, allowing them to better understand phonics and spelling instruction. Invented spelling is particularly important with children initially low in phoneme awareness. Children who are aware of phonemes do not need to invent spellings since they already possess the chief benefit of this activity.
We want students to write for communicative purposes, to tell us something they think is important. The urge to communicate is the prime motive for writing. We will greatly reduce children’s output (and thus their phoneme awareness practice) if we insist on turning message writing into an exercise, e.g., by requiring certain words.
Message writing is not the time to teach standard spelling. After a child has written, simply appreciate the message and respond to the ideas. Have the student read you the message, and if the spelling departs significantly from standard spelling, transcribe it below the original message. This will not hurt the child’s feelings; it says, “What you wrote is so important that I want to write in grown-up writing to remember exactly what it says.” Be sure to give specific praise (e.g., for a phonemic spelling or well-turned phrase) and post the message prominently.
To get the message started, you will want to suggest topics your student could write about. The topic suggestions might grow from a conversation during your initial greeting to the student; you may hear of a sports triumph, a family outing, or the antics of a baby sister. Upcoming holidays (especially Halloween, Christmas, Valentines Day, Easter, and Independence Day) often capture a child’s imagination and make good writing topics. You can also encourage writing by putting up an illustration. Pictures can make a powerful stimulus to the imagination (which is why they are used in projective tests). You can model the form and content of a message by writing messages to your student. You may want to make a cardstock “mailbox” to send and receive messages.
The following examples show the kind of concrete and colorful talk that make letter forms memorable to children and guide their printing and letter recognition:
For capital A, start at the rooftop, go down the slide to the sidewalk, then down the slide the other way, and cross at the fence.
For lowercase a, don’t start at the fence. Start under the fence. Go up and touch the fence, then around and touch the sidewalk, around and straight down.
For capital B, go straight down to the sidewalk, around for his big chest, and around for his big tummy.
For lowercase b, start at the roof, go down, b-b-bounce up and around.
For capital C, start just below the rooftop, go up to touch, around, and up.
For lowercase c, start like little a: Go up and touch the fence, then around and up.
For capital D, start at the roof, go straight down, pick up, and go around.
For lowercase d, first little c, then little d.
For capital E, go down for a strong backbone, over for his hat, over for his belt, over for his shoes.
For lowercase e, get in the center of the space below the fence; go toward the door (or window), up to touch the fence, around and up.
For capital F, go down, over for his hat, over for his belt (but no shoes).
For lowercase f, start to make a little c up in the air, then straighten it out, go down, and cross at the fence.
For capital G, form a big C, then come back to the line to give him a tray to hold straight.
For lowercase g, first make a, then, gee, that’s a good idea: If the ball falls, it falls into the basket.
For capital H, down for a wall, down for a wall, then cross at the fence.
For lowercase h, start at the rooftop, come down, and hump over.
For capital I, start with a straight back, then give him his headdress and his moccasins.
For lowercase i, go down from the fence, and give him a feather.
For capital J, go down, and turn to make a basket, and put his hat on.
For lowercase j, start at the fence, go down through the sidewalk, and turn the same way, and give him a dot.
For capital K, go down, come out here, into the center, and down to the sidewalk.
Lowercase k is just as tall as his daddy. Start at the rooftop, go down, pick up at the fence, into the center and down.
For capital L, go down and turn the corner.
For lowercase l, just a straight line down from the rooftop to the sidewalk.
For capital M, go down straight, down the slide, up the slide, and down straight.
For lowercase m, go down, hump around, hump around.
For capital N, go down straight, down the slide, down straight.
For lowercase n, go down, up, and hump over.
For capital O, always form a C first, and then close it up.
For lowercase o, same way: first a little c and close it up.
For capital P, go down, pick up, and around to the fence.
For lowercase p, start at the fence, go straight down into the ditch, come up and put his chin on the sidewalk.
For capital Q, first make a big O, and give the queen her walking stick.
For lowercase q, start with an a, come down, and give the queen some curly hair.
For capital R, down, pick up, and around to the fence, then slant down.
For lowercase r, down, up, and hook over.
For capital S, first form a c up in the air between the rooftop and the fence, then swing back.
For lowercase s, form a tiny c up in the air, and then swing back.
For capital T, go down and cross at the top.
Lowercase t is just a teenager, not as tall as his daddy, but not short either; cross at the fence.
For capital U, down, curve, and up (no stem).
For lowercase u, down, curve up, and straight down for a stem.
For capital V, slant down and up.
For lowercase v, slant down and up.
For capital W, slant down, up, down, up.
For lowercase w, down, up, down, up.
For capital X, down on a slant, pick up, back in the other direction.
For lowercase x, down and back.
For capital Y, start with a v up in the air, and put a stem on it.
For lowercase y, go down on a slant, pick up your pencil, slant down, touch, and on into the ditch.
For capital Z, make a 7, and then go back.
For lowercase z, make a little 7, and then go back.
Return to the Reading Genie homepage.
Last modified: February 18, 2021